A version of this story appeared in the CNN Business Nightcap newsletter. To get it in your inbox, sign up for free here.
Elon Musk’s plan for saving Tesla is blowing up faster than a SpaceX rocket.
It was supposed to go like this: Musk, who became a chainsaw-wielding MAGA acolyte, would ditch the DC sideshow and get back to business. His empire was flailing without him, and Tesla, especially, was in a tailspin. Investors were clamoring for that old Musk magic to revive sales and pivot the electric vehicle company into an AI juggernaut worthy of its (still lofty) share price.
Turns out, you can take the CEO out of DC but you can’t take the DC out of the CEO.
Tesla (TSLA) is expected to report yet another quarter of declining global sales on Wednesday, a not-unexpected stumble after months of falling revenue thanks to increased competition in the EV market and no small amount of reputational damage stemming from Musk’s role as President Trump’s “first buddy.”
Now, you might imagine that if you’re the CEO of a company with sales of its core product in rapid decline you’d want to, like, avoid any public squabbles that would further undermine investors’ confidence in your leadership.
Or, you could take the Musk route.
This week, barely a month after he left his role as a special government adviser to focus on reviving Tesla, Musk was once again rolling in the beltway muck, picking another fight with Trump over the president’s deficit-exploding tax and spending bill.
Musk called Trump’s signature legislation “insane” and threatened to primary Republicans in Congress who vote for it. Trump responded with a suggestion that his administration could investigate Musk’s companies’ government contracts.
(You know, real grown-up stuff.)
“This BFF situation has now turned into a soap opera that remains an overhang on Tesla’s stock,” Wedbush analyst Dan Ives, a longtime Tesla defender, said in a note to clients Tuesday. “Tesla investors want Musk to focus on driving Tesla and stop this political angle… being on Trump’s bad side will not turn out well, and Musk knows this.”
Ives remains bullish on Tesla, but in recent months he has been speaking out about the damage Musk’s political swings have done to the company’s image, which isn’t helping the company’s sales problem.
Ahead of Wednesday’s report, analysts had forecast that Tesla sales sank 13% in the April-June period compared with a year earlier. The consensus from data provider FactSet had Tesla logging 387,000 deliveries in the quarter, compared with 444,000 a year earlier. That could end up being even worse than the first quarter, when Tesla reported its sharpest year-over-year sales decline ever.
Sales are hardly Tesla’s only problem.
The company saw a 71% drop in net income in the first quarter. Its showrooms have been pummeled with protests. The Cybertruck is a flop. Republicans and Democrats say they are less likely to buy a Tesla now than they were before Musk’s stint in the White House, according to a new Electric Vehicle Intelligence Report released Tuesday.
And, as my colleague Chris Isidore reported last month, it’s actually worse than all of that.
If you look closely at Tesla’s first-quarter earnings, you’ll see that Tesla is losing money on what should be its core business: selling cars. In short, Tesla only managed a $409 million profit last quarter thanks to the sale of $595 million worth of regulatory credits to other automakers.
But if Trump succeeds in passing his signature spending bill, those credits will evaporate.
That’s just one of many reasons investors like Ives are hoping that Musk and Trump can bury the hatchet (or, at the very least, that Musk can keep his mouth shut for five minutes).
Tesla relies on credits to stay profitable, but it also needs favorable regulations just to give it a fighting chance at competing with rivals like Waymo, the Alphabet-owned driverless taxi company that’s already running circles around Tesla.
Tesla shares, the backbone of Musk’s personal fortune, are down 37% from their post-election peak, when Musk was becoming a fixture at Mar-a-Lago. The thinking on Wall Street back then was that Tesla’s problems were manageable, and that any blowback from the company’s liberal base would be outweighed by the benefit of having Musk in the White House, influencing regulations.
It might have worked, briefly. But the pair’s falling out now has investors worried Trump will aim his retribution directly at Tesla.
As the Musk-Trump feud reignited Monday, Tesla shares sank 2%. They fell another 5% on Tuesday, missing out on the broader stock market rally.
The message may be getting through to Musk. After Trump commented that DOGE, the committee Musk set up to slash the federal bureaucracy, could be a “monster” that will “go back and eat Elon,” Musk seemed to hold back. Kind of.
“So tempting to escalate this. So, so tempting,” he wrote on X. “But I will refrain for now.”
Read the full article here